App Review: Hemingway Editor

What do you think? Can a software tool improve your writing?

The debate’s been raging for years. Some say that only a human editor can understand the nuances of text draft.

That hasn’t stopped software developers from trying to create that perfect software editing tool. The latest entry into the software editing arena is the Hemingway Editor app.

Named after the author famous for his short, concise sentences–the app’s goal is to help you improve your writing. More on how the app goes about that later…

In this post, I share my thoughts on the latest version of the Hemingway Editor app. I discuss how the new version differs from the old version. I explain what I like about each version. And I explore where I’d like to see this app go in the future.

How I Learned About the App

I discovered the Hemingway app a little over a year ago. At the time I only had access to the online version. I included it with some other tools in the post, 4 Fun Tools to Check Your Writing. When the desktop Hemingway app was offered for a fairly low price, I got a copy. Later, I included the online tool again in my list of helpful editing sites.

A few weeks ago, I got a welcome surprise in my email. It turns out that they’ve upgraded Hemingway desktop app. Since I purchased the original desktop app, they sent me the upgraded app.

Let me start by admitting something. I spend a lot of time editing my own writing. Of course, I’m not the only one. Most writers I know do the same thing.

I mention this because there’s a myth out there that a good writer “gets it right the first time.” That’s not been my experience. When I send a draft to a client I’ve already gone over that draft two or three times.

Why do I go over my drafts? Well, of course I’m looking for mistakes like grammar errors and misspellings. But I’m also looking at style. How well did I say that? Was I too wordy? How does the piece flow?

That’s why I need more than a simple grammar or spelling checker. Let’s look at some of the ways that the Hemingway Editor has helped me (and how it might help you).

Hemingway Editing Features

The first version of Hemingway started out by flagging five writing problems:

1. Hard to read sentences (yellow)
2. Very hard to read sentences (pink)
3. Complex words or phrases (purple)
4. Adverbs (blue)
5. Passive voice (green)

It also gave you some quick counts such as:

• Number of paragraphs
• Number of sentences
• Number of words
• Number of characters

Plus, it gives your writing a readability score and assigns a grade level. There’s a writing mode (which turns off the editing features) and an edit mode. A basic spellchecker underlines misspelled words with red dashes, but offers no alternative spellings.

I have to admit, I never created text from within Hemingway. I’ve only used the edit mode. I also don’t pay attention to the counters. If a client wanted an exact word or character count, I guess the counters could be helpful.

The other editing features have been helpful. If Hemingway flags something in my writing, I think twice about leaving it in.

New Hemingway Features

The latest version of the Hemingway tool adds formatting features. The addition really got my attention. One service I perform for some  copywriting clients is to give them WordPress-ready formatted text.

To do this, I either type HTML codes into my text editor or copy the draft into WordPress and use the formatting tools there. Either method is a little clunky.

The original Hemingway app had a Preview HTML option under the View menu. It also had the option to export text to HTML. I never used either feature–partly because I didn’t know how and partly because I viewed Hemingway as a style editing tool.

The formatting tools in the latest version of Hemingway mean that you can now use it to format text in HTML. Most basic formatting options are there:

• Bold
• Italics
• Unordered list
• Ordered list
• Outdent
• Indent
• Hyperlink
• Paragraph
• Heading 1
• Heading 2
• Heading 3

For me, this may mean an easier way to offer formatted copy to clients.

This version of Hemingway also adds Read Time to the counters. Frankly this addition puzzles me a little. While it’s interesting, I’m not sure how this is calculated. Everyone reads at a different rate.

Also, you can now choose between four different types of English. Set your spellchecker for:

• American English
• British English
• Australian English
• Canadian English

This is interesting and potentially useful for me. I have had clients in both Canada and Australia. I’ve also had a few clients ask that I use British spellings.

My Hemingway Wishlist

I think the Hemingway Editor app is headed in the right direction. It’s moved from being an occasional tool to check my style to being closer to a tool I might write in.

There are still some features I’d like to see, though. Here’s my wishlist for future versions:

• A WSIWYG preview for the HTML formatting. I want to see what formatted text will look like after it’s published in WordPress.
• A full-fledged spellchecker. It’s nice that misspelled words are underlined. But if you don’t know the correct spelling, you still have to leave the tool to look it up.
• Version compare. As a writer, I sometimes compare original drafts with later versions. This would be a nice addition.
• Quotes formatting. The formatting features included with the latest version don’t include block quotes. They’d make another nice addition.
• Citation help. It would be helpful to have a tool that helps me flag and format citations in one or more acceptable styles.

Conclusion

I realize there are many good authoring tools out there. At a one-time cost of $9.99 (as of July 2015), this tool is a bargain even if you only use the style editing aspects.

Do you use the Hemingway Editor app? What has your experience  been like? What do you think of the new release?

Leave your answers in the comments.